Warren Throckmorton

By Warren Throckmorton
November 9, 2026

Texas Monthly journalist Robert Downen makes a good case that the Christian nationalist agenda took a major hit during the midterm elections. Up and down the ballot in Texas and elsewhere, Christian nationalist candidates and office holders went down to defeat. In response, he states in an article dated November 5, “The Christian Nationalist Agenda is Dead.”

If only.

Downen is one of my favorite journalists, but I don’t agree. In fact, he doesn’t fully agree either. Near the end of his article, he quotes Anthea Butler correctly saying Christian nationalists take the long view.

“I think they’re going to have to crawl under a rock and figure out what to do next,” Butler said. But she cautioned against pronouncing Christian nationalism entirely dead—politically speaking, it is a movement that thinks and plots in generations, if not longer.

Yes, Christian nationalist politicians took it on the chin last week. However, many of them see losing as part of a greater plan and will keep trying to advance their cause. True believers rarely self-reflect; they find ways to explain setbacks within their existing views. Being rejected by the American public isn’t reason to question their views. They attribute their defeat to trials imposed by God, or, alternatively, demonic activity.

This is a movement which has been active across many decades. For instance, David Barton began his public activities in 1989 and has weathered numerous setbacks and political reversals. He isn’t going to let a blue wave stop him. In fact, he is just reframing the whole thing. He recently said on his podcast that there wasn’t a blue wave, merely the absence of a red one.

Social psychological research has demonstrated over the years that movements often increase their proselytizing activities in the face of adversity. I expect Christian nationalists to do the same. The recent election results are a setback for many Christian nationalist politicians who expected to legislate their theology, but the agenda and the movement will continue. They may or may not operate more quietly, but they will continue.

This column was originally published on The Throckmorton Initiative, a blog written by Warren Throckmorton.

Warren Throckmorton retired from Grove City College.  He now writes about Christian nationalism, religion, history, and politics at The Throckmorton Initiative.  To learn more about subscribing to The Throckmorton Initiative, click here.

The views and opinions expressed do not necessarily reflect the views of The Indiana Citizen or any other affiliated organization.


📝 View all posts by Marilyn Odendahl


Related Posts