By Marilyn Odendahl
The Indiana Citizen
November 17, 2026
After he took the oath of office Tuesday afternoon and became the Indiana Senate president pro tem, Sen. Chris Garten described the court battle over his reelection and whether he should be allowed to fill his seat in the legislature with one word: “lawfare.”
“This is not simply a request to recount ballots,” Garten, R-Charlestown, said following the recess of the Senate session. “This was an effort to prevent a reported election winner from taking office. I believe that distinction matters. There’s a word increasingly used to describe the weaponization of legal proceedings for political purposes: ‘lawfare.’”
Nearly 24 hours prior, Garten’s ability to join the 125th Indiana General Assembly, let alone become president pro tem, was in doubt.
The Clark County Circuit Court at 3:44 p.m. on Monday granted a motion for a temporary restraining order that blocked the certification of the Indiana Senate District 45 race and essentially prohibited Garten from participating in Organization Day, the ceremonial start of the 2027 legislative session, at the Statehouse.
The motion was filed by Clark County Democratic Party Chair Miguel Hampton and is part of a lawsuit seeking a judicial review of the certification of Garten’s narrow victory in Senate District 45, which includes Clark and portions of Floyd counties. Party leaders have been pointing to discrepancies in voting machine tabulations and questioning whether all the votes cast in four Jeffersonville precincts on Election Day were counted. They turned to the court after the Clark County Election Board passed two resolutions denying the request to count the paper ballots.
Following Monday’s ruling, Clark County Democratic Party Chair Miguel Hampton, Indiana Democratic Party Chair Karen Tallian, and Ninth District Democratic Party Chair Adam Dickey issued a joint statement, saying the trial court had made the correct decision.
“Hoosiers can rest assured the will of the people will be honored in the election, no matter the final result,” the party leaders said Monday. “We will continue doing everything in our power to ensure these discrepancies are addressed and every legal vote was accurately counted.”

Garten’s legal team, led by attorney James Bopp, made an emergency appeal to the Indiana Supreme Court for relief. In part, Bopp argued that the restraining order was not only keeping Garten from his seat but also depriving the constituents in Senate District 45 of representation in the Senate.
The Indiana Supreme Court granted part of the emergency writ, which overturned the temporary restraining order order that was blocking Garten from taking the oath and being seated. Signed by Chief Justice Loretta Rush, the order left in place the portion of the restraining order that prevents the results of the Senate District 45 race from being certified.
Garten pointed out that state statute has established a procedure for recounts and contests in close elections. Revealing that he is filing a petition for a recount in his race, he said he welcomes the transparency and accountability that will come with a recount, but he criticized the legal maneuvering of the Democratic Party leaders.
“In my view, these actions created unnecessary election chaos and brought Indiana to the brink of constitutional confrontation over a disputed election,” Garten said. “And who would have paid the price? Not Democrats, not Republicans, not the attorneys, but the people that I represent, Hoosiers of Senate District 45, the families, the taxpayers, the small business owners, working Hoosiers who deserve a voice in their state government. I refuse to treat that as ordinary politics.”
Senate Minority Leader Shelli Yoder, D-Bloomington, sidestepped a question about Garten’s assertion that the case against him is politically motivated. She responded by talking about affordability and finding ways to bring down the cost of living for Hoosiers.
Asked whether the Senate should have elected Garten president pro tem while his reelection is being contested, Yoder pointed to the Supreme Court’s ruling and said the Republican leader can exercise his right to seek a recount in an attempt to confirm his win.
As for whether she was worried the election dispute in Clark County would deter voters, Yoder said she thinks this will give voters confidence in the election process.
“I actually think it demonstrates that every vote counts, that votes do matter,” Yoder said.
Rush was at the Statehouse Tuesday, swearing in members of the Indiana House and Senate, including Garten.
Court rules prevented Rush from commenting on the cases pending before the Indiana Supreme Court. However, in a statement, she said, “It is a privilege to welcome new and returning members of the General Assembly. I am honored to administer the oath of office today to these Hoosiers.”
Sydney Byerly, reporter for The Indiana Citizen, contributed to this story.
The Indiana Citizen is a nonpartisan, nonprofit platform dedicated to increasing the number of informed and engaged Hoosier citizens. We are operated by the Indiana Citizen Education Foundation, Inc., a 501(c)(3) public charity. For questions about the story, contact Marilyn Odendahl at marilyn.odendahl@indianacitizen.org.