Fifteen judicial races were contested in the 2026 midterm election and four incumbent judges were defeated. (Photo/Pexels.com)

By Marilyn Odendahl
The Indiana Citizen
November 20, 2026

The daughter of a retiring Allen County Superior Court judge and a Madison County Circuit Court judge who was suspended for 45 days in 2024 because his actions were found to have “damaged the … public trust in the judiciary” were among the Indiana trial court judges who won their races in the 2026 midterm elections.

Of the 15 competitive judicial contests across Indiana, eight races were against incumbents and seven were for open seats. Four sitting judges, three of whom were Republicans, lost their bids for another term.

Christina Gull, daughter of retiring Allen County Judge Fran Gull, defeated two opponents in a nonpartisan race and will replace her mother in the Superior Court No. 5 seat. Also, Jerry Smith, deputy attorney general in Indiana Attorney General Todd Rokita’s office, won his race and will become the judge in Morgan County Superior Court No. 1.

Porter County Superior Court No. 4 Judge Christopher Buckley, who has been charged with judicial misconduct by the Indiana Commission on Judicial Qualifications, lost his bid for reelection, while Vigo County Superior Court No. 5 Judge Matthew Sheehan and Madison County Circuit Court No. 5 Judge Scott Norrick, both of whom were sanctioned by the Judicial Qualifications Commission, won their races.

Overall, eight judges running as Democrats won and six judges running as Republicans won. The race for Allen County Superior Court was nonpartisan.

New Albany attorney Derrick Wilson, who serves as the president of the Indiana State Bar Association but spoke to The Indiana Citizen on his own behalf, attributed the outcome to the blue wave that swept across the ballot.

Judicial candidates running as Democrats got a lift, he said.

“My complete layperson’s read is you had so many people showing up on the Democratic side that if you were running as a Republican, it was going to be much more tight than it has been traditionally,” Wilson said.

In nine races for the small claims courts in Marion County, only Perry Township Judge Cheryl Rivera, a Republican, was challenged in the election. Democrat Jami Sayeed pulled the upset, winning 50.3% of the vote, to Rivera’s 49.7%.

Although many Hoosiers may continue to struggle to make an informed choice when voting for a judge, Wilson, managing partner at Mattox & Wilson, noted a change in the way candidates campaign for the bench.

“It used to be a judge would be the person you never hear from because they will run a very low-key race and they will not talk about their feelings on a particular issue,” Wilson said. “Now, I think, there is a sense that you can’t just remain silent. You’ve got to take some little positions on a few things.”

However, Wilson believes voters casting ballots in judicial races are most swayed by the letter after the candidates’ names. Even though the contests for the bench are supposed to be apolitical, he said, voters are still looking at party affiliation.

The results of the judicial races for the county superior and circuit court judges are listed below as well as results of the judicial retention votes.

County trial court judges

Incumbent judges who were defeated

Clark County Circuit Court No. 3
Andrea Wasson Stemle (D) ….. 53.3%
Judge Lisa Glickfield (R) ….. 46.7%
LaPorte County Superior Court No. 1
Michael S. Bergerson (D) ….. 54.6%
Judge Jaime Oss (R) ….. 45.4%
Switzerland County Circuit Court
Michelle Hicks (R) ….. 50.8%
Judge W. Gregory Coy (D) ….. 49.2%
Porter County Superior Court No. 4
Heather McCarthy (D) ….. 57.9%
Judge Christopher Buckley (R) ….. 42.1%

Incumbent judges who won

Dubois County Circuit Court
Judge Nathan Verkamp (D) ….. 57.0%
Brian Lucchi (R) ….. 43.0%
Vigo County Superior Court No. 5
Judge Matthew Sheehan (D) ….. 51.4%
Robert Roberts (R) ….. 42.1%
Madison County Circuit Court  No. 5
Judge Scott Norrick (R) ….. 54.6%
Emilee Hammond (D) ….. 45.4%
Randolph County Superior Court
Judge Olivia Faddis (R) ….. 71.6%
Christen Commers Smith (D) ….. 28.4%

Open seats

Allen County Superior Court No. 5 (nonpartisan)
Christina Gull ….. 47.2%
Samuel Keirns ….. 27.7%
Jesus “Rick” Trevino ….. 25.1%
Delaware County Circuit Court No. 5
Amanda Dunnuck (D) ….. 57.7%
Ben Freeman (R) ….. 42.3%
Floyd County Superior Court No. 3
Maxwell McCrite (R) ….. 51.0%
Christina Knavely (D) ….. 49.0%
Hamilton County Superior Court No. 8
Emily L. Angel Shaw (D) ….. 52.5%
Danica L. Eyler (R) ….. 47.5%
LaPorte County Superior Court No. 3
James Macalka (D) ….. 54.7%
Kurt Earnst (R) ….. 45.3%
Morgan County Superior Court No. 1
Jerry Smith (R) ….. 58.1%
Jarrett Ksenak (L) ….. 41.9%
Wayne County Superior Court No. 2
Austin Shadle (R) ….. 62.7%
Jessica Richert (I) ….. 37.3%

Indiana appellate and tax court judges

All three Court of Appeals of Indiana judges on the ballot and the Indiana Tax Court judge were all retained by comfortable margins.

The percentage of “yes” votes for the Court of Appeals judges
Judge Mary A. DeBoer (4th district) ….. 74%
Judge Paul A. Felix (5th district) ….. 72%
Judge Dana J. Kenworthy (2nd district) ….. 76%

Tax Court Judge Justin McAdam was retained with 73% of the vote.

Trial court judges on ballot for retention  

Lake, Marion and St. Joseph counties all had superior court judges on the ballot for retention. All were all retained.

Marion County Superior Court Judge Geoffrey Gaither, who was narrowly recommended for retention by the Marion County Judicial Selection Committee and has been charged with three counts of judicial misconduct by the Judicial Qualifications Commission was retained with 65.4%.

The percentage of “yes” votes

Lake County
Julie Cantrell ….. 71.2%
Nicholas Schiralli ….. 69.5%
John Sedia ….. 68.6%
St. Joseph County
David Francisco ….. 73.4%
Christopher Fronk ….. 71.8%
Marion County
Richard Blaiklock ….. 68.8%
Marshelle Dawkins Broadwell ….. 72.4%
David Certo ….. 69.6%
Angela Dow-Davis ….. 75.4%
Patrick Dietrick ….. 70.1%
Kurt Eisgruber ….. 66.8%
Geoffrey Gaither ….. 65.4%
Ryan Gardner ….. 71.2%
Melanie Kendrick ….. 76.1%
Christina Klineman ….. 74.5%
Patricia McMath ….. 74.3%
Timothy Oakes ….. 68.6%
Marc Rothenberg ….. 68.4%
Philip Sheward ….. 69.5%

Dwight Adams, an editor and writer based in Indianapolis, edited this article. He is a former content editor, copy editor and digital producer at The Indianapolis Star and IndyStar.com, and worked as a planner for other newspapers, including the Louisville Courier Journal. 

The Indiana Citizen is a nonpartisan, nonprofit platform dedicated to increasing the number of informed and engaged Hoosier citizens. We are operated by the Indiana Citizen Education Foundation, Inc., a 501(c)(3) public charity. For questions about the story, contact Marilyn Odendahl at marilyn.odendahl@indianacitizen.org.

 

 




Related Posts