By TheStatehouseFile.com
December 12, 2025
From the White House to the Statehouse, reactions to Thursday’s defeat of mid-cycle redistricting in the Indiana Senate have been pouring in, and many lawmakers are explaining their votes.
Senate President Pro Tem Rodric Bray, R-Martinsville, who voted no: “Indiana Senate Republicans want to see a Republican majority in congress at the midterms. The issue before us today was how to get there, and many of my caucus members don’t think redrawing our Congressional map mid-cycle is a guaranteed way for Indiana—or our country—to achieve that outcome.
“We support President Trump, and we are with him on many important issues like immigration enforcement and public safety, and Hoosiers will see legislation from our caucus this session that works in partnership with the federal government to further those efforts.
“Further, we are grateful for the way President Trump speaks about our great nation full of good people.
“It’s time to turn the page. Hoosiers need leadership from their state government that will continue to improve our education system and make life more affordable for Hoosiers.”
Sen. Kyle Walker, R-Lawrence, who voted no: “I understand the many reasons why some supported pursuing mid-decade redistricting. There are thoughtful arguments on all sides, and I respect my colleagues who believe this approach was necessary. However, I simply could not support an effort to redraw legislative districts in the middle of a decade solely for political purposes. Our commitment to democracy requires predictability, transparency and public trust.
“Over the past few months, I have heard directly from thousands of constituents who expressed concern about the timing and the long-term implications of mid-decade redistricting. Their feedback underscored the importance of maintaining confidence in the process and ensuring that any changes to district boundaries occur with broad public input and clear justification.
“For these reasons, I respectfully voted no. My decision reflects both my commitment to representative democracy and my responsibility to the people I serve.”
Sen. Greg Goode, R-Terre Haute, who voted no: “My job as state senator is to best represent District 38 and the Hoosiers who call it home. Throughout this process, I have worked hard to be accessible and hear directly from the residents of Clay, Sullivan and Vigo counties.
“In addition to being the only Republican legislator in Indiana to host a listening session on this issue, I spoke with numerous constituents individually and reviewed all correspondence I received from my district. The overwhelming feedback from constituents, regardless of political leaning or party affiliation, clearly demonstrated that the consensus of Hoosiers in District 38 is to vote against HB 1032.
“The feedback focused on three main concerns:
“First, my constituents are disappointed that the proposed map would split the counties of the Wabash Valley into two congressional districts. These counties, with strong encouragement from the state, are working collaboratively as an economic development region and currently have clear, straightforward representation by our member of Congress. Splitting these counties into separate congressional districts would create confusion and barriers to cooperation.
“Second, Clay County residents are unhappy that their county would be drawn into a district with Indianapolis and central Indiana suburbs, which would dilute the voices of this important rural county. There are many in west-central Indiana who have not forgotten how Indianapolis-based politicians secretly planned the LEAP district—benefitting Boone County—with the very real threat of taking millions of gallons of water every day from our Wabash River. I intervened in that issue and understood why my constituents in Clay County and the northern Wabash River counties would be frustrated if they were drawn into a district with Indianapolis and Boone County.
“Third, for years, Senate District 38 enjoyed the public service of my predecessor, State Sen. Jon Ford, who chaired the State Senate Elections Committee in 2021 that produced the congressional map observed today. This map was the result of steadfast and earnest work as well as multiple hearings across the state. It is one that most Hoosiers agree with, and the current map has encountered no lawsuits. Many constituents raised concerns that implementing new maps in such a short period of time could result in lengthy lawsuits that would be both expensive to the taxpayer and place immense pressure on our county clerks. Additionally, some Republican constituents expressed concern that maps would politically backfire on Indiana Republican congressional incumbents and candidates, particularly in the 8th Congressional District. …
“I have done my very best to quietly and respectfully listen to the people I represent, and I am confident that my vote reflects the will of my constituents.”
Sen. Andy Zay, R-Huntington, who voted yes: “Throughout this process, I have remained supportive of strengthening Indiana’s congressional districts and believe thoughtful redistricting is an important part of ensuring every Hoosier’s voice is fairly represented.
“Where we fell short as a state was in failing to fully help Hoosiers understand why redistricting matters and to bring Hoosiers along with us in this conversation. I also strongly believe in respecting Gov. Braun’s role, and when the executive branch calls a special session, the General Assembly has a responsibility to convene and do its work. That is why I opposed the resolution on Organization Day that would have delayed our return until January.
“Although HB 1032 failed to pass, I remain committed to ensuring all Hoosiers understand the reasoning behind redistricting and upholding a transparent process moving forward.”
Sen. Jean Leising, R-Oldenburg, who voted no: “Mid-cycle congressional redistricting in Indiana failed on the Senate floor yesterday with my ‘no’ vote.
“I believe it is time to move on to our normal session schedule and focus on issues affecting our local communities, like addressing the availability of affordable rural health care and good jobs so Indiana residents can provide for their families.
“I will continue to fight for the needs of my constituents as we prepare for session in January.”
Sen. Vaneta Becker, R-Evansville, who voted no: “Over the past months of conversation regarding the issue of redistricting, I heard over 1,000 people in my district tell me this is not what they wanted and only 100 favor it. I always do my best to represent my constituents, and with that in mind, I voted ‘no.’ I am glad to see this bill fail to pass.”
Sen. Blake Doriot, R-Goshen, who voted no: “Yesterday’s vote was the hardest choice I have had to make during my time at the Senate. I spent a very long time researching this issue and speaking to people both in Washington, D.C. and my local community. I’d like to thank all those who shared their input with me in a passionate and polite manner, especially the constituents I was elected to represent.
“The proposed maps would have split Elkhart County into two different congressional districts, separating our shared community into two distinct populations. Elkhart County wasn’t the only one being split–Marion County was also separated further into four different districts. I felt the proposed plan put several districts, including historically red districts, at risk of being flipped.
“Most importantly, I represent those who live in Elkhart County. I heard from friends, neighbors and people I had never met before who overwhelmingly stated they were not in support of this and were concerned that the proposed changes would only hurt our community. My vote reflected those concerns, and I stand by my decision to vote against this bill to support those who rely on me to represent them.”
Sen. Linda Rogers, R-Granger, who voted no: “Today, I joined the majority of my colleagues in voting against redistricting. Over the last few months, I have heard from thousands of constituents who were overwhelmingly opposed. When I chose to run for Senate District 11, I promised to serve and advocate for those in our local community, and I believe I upheld that promise today. I will continue to work on issues affecting all Hoosiers, including education reform and reducing taxes.”
Sen. Gary Byrne, R-Byrneville, who voted yes: “I am disappointed that the Senate failed to pass House Bill 1032, which would have redrawn Indiana’s congressional maps to ensure our conservative voice is heard in Washington, D.C.
“Our state had a huge chance to help our country at a time when we needed it most, and we missed it. I will continue to fight for my constituents in Senate District 47 and continue to fight to protect our conservative values no matter what.”
Megan Robertson, executive director of Indiana Conservation Voters: “Today is a win for Hoosiers, and a win for our democracy. Lawmakers listened and made the right choice, and we are grateful.
“By halting this unnecessary and deeply unpopular attempt to redraw Indiana’s Congressional maps mid-decade, the Senate affirmed what people across our state have been saying for months: Hoosier leaders need to be focused on issues that affect our everyday lives, not a misguided plan to redraw maps that were just drawn four years ago.
“Washington’s effort to carve up our communities and shift political power for partisan gain was the wrong approach from the start. We’re grateful to every Hoosier who showed up—in the cold, at committee hearings, via calls and emails—to make their voices heard. That advocacy is why we celebrate today.
“Now, we can finally put this chapter behind us and get back to work on what really matters: lowering energy bills and addressing affordability. Indiana faces real challenges, and Hoosiers have said time and again over the past four months that we want our leaders focused on solving them.”
Indiana Democratic Party Chair Karen Tallian: “Today marks the end of a battle. The Indiana General Assembly has rules. Redistricting happens every ten years. These rules are not obstacles. They are safety nets. Upholding the rules is not an act of weakness—it is an act of responsibility: maintaining the integrity of the process and preserving the legitimacy and credibility of the institution. Today, that’s what my former colleagues did by rejecting this partisan sideshow.
“There is an old adage: Democracy is not a spectator sport. Today, Hoosiers proved that.
“Hoosiers stood up, and were heard. In town hall meetings, rallies at the Statehouse and in thousands of texts, emails, letters and phone calls to legislators urging them to reject this blatant power play.
“Thankfully, at least some of our legislators listened. Some of our legislators had the courage to stand up, despite the vile hurled at them.
“So, I say to folks all over Indiana: your voices matter. Thank you for your participation. Today, the people won.”
Rep. Victoria Garcia Wilburn, D-Fishers: “Yesterday, the Senate constitutionally defeated HB 1032 and prevented one of the worst days in the Indiana General Assembly. Sen. Pro Tem Bray said three different times that they did not have the votes, and here we are. A win for Hoosiers.
“Thank you to everyone who spoke up, contacted lawmakers and made it clear that Hoosiers expect transparency, fairness and real accountability. Your advocacy mattered. This outcome happened because thousands of people came together and refused to be ignored.
“Hoosier values prevailed. Equal competition prevailed. Because of you, this rushed and unnecessary redistricting plan will not move forward.
“Now, we can regain focus on what really matters: the fact that everyday Hoosiers are struggling to make ends meet due to the rising cost of living. Yesterday’s decision belongs to the people who showed up and used their voices.
“This is a moment to celebrate and a reminder of your power. When we organize, we make change.
“Stay engaged. Stay vocal. Together, we will keep fighting for a government that puts Hoosiers first.”
Rep. Matt Pierce, D-Bloomington: “Today was a win for democracy and the people of Indiana. Unlike the House, a majority of Senators stood up for the Hoosier values of fairness and integrity, rejecting Washington, D.C.’s naked power grab. Hoosiers want healthy competition in their politics. That’s how the will of the people gets translated into the policies they want.
“Now that this sad chapter of the General Assembly’s history is over, it’s time for the legislature to apply the same sense of urgency and effort to solving the real problems facing Hoosiers. Too many people are living paycheck to paycheck. Costs continue to skyrocket for groceries, health care, utilities, and child care. I look forward to leaving partisan issues behind and working to improve the lives of all Hoosiers.”
Rep. Chris Campbell, D-West Lafayette: “I am proud of our senators who stood up for fairness and democracy instead of partisan politics. Now that this is behind us, I hope the legislature will focus on making Indiana more affordable for Hoosier families by lowering health care costs, utility bills and the cost of child care.”
Rep. Sheila Klinker, D-Lafayette: “I am grateful that our friends in the Senate made the right decision for our communities. Tippecanoe County will remain whole, preserving our ability to work cohesively. Thank you to those in my community who called, emailed and participated in this issue. I deeply value your input and the important role you play in our democracy.”
Rep. Carey Hamilton, D-Indianapolis, House minority caucus chair: “Four months have been spent with our attention on mid-decade redistricting instead of on what we were elected to do: serving our constituents. I celebrate this opportunity to get back on track and focus on the true needs of Hoosiers. Come January, I look forward to working on making healthcare, childcare, utilities, housing and groceries more affordable for working families.
“Hoosiers from across the state and across the political spectrum showed up in a way I have never seen before. This outcome could not have happened without the thousands of people who got involved and stood up for fairness. I want to thank everyone who took part in this movement, from the protestors to those who emailed and called their legislators. Now, let’s get back to work.”
Rep. Mike Andrade, D-Munster: “Hoosiers’ voices were heard today, and communities were kept together. Redistricting has failed in our state, but this vote was a step toward rebuilding public trust in a system that too often leaves people behind.
“I hope we can put mid-cycle redistricting behind us and refocus on the real issues impacting Hoosiers—affordability, healthcare and rising utility costs.
“I will continue to fight for the voices of the people and remain focused on the issues that matter most to Hoosier families.”
Rep. Cherrish Pryor, D-Indianapolis, House minority floor leader and a member of the House Committee on Elections and Apportionment: “For four months, the conversation has been centered around whether Republicans in the Indiana General Assembly will redraw our congressional maps. Finally, we can put this mess behind us to focus on what Hoosiers really need, like more affordable utilities, healthcare, childcare, housing and groceries.
“The rejection of House Bill 1032 is a win for all Hoosiers. Everyone benefits from having their voice heard in our democracy and getting to choose who represents them in congress. I am glad that Marion County and my district will stay united under one congressional district so that our unique needs will be advocated for.
“This relieving outcome was only reached because of all of the many Hoosiers who showed up from across the state to advocate against mid-decade gerrymandering. Whether you wrote a letter, made a phone call, showed up to a town hall or joined a protest, thank you for elevating this issue and standing up for our state. I look forward to fighting to make life better and more affordable for all Hoosiers this January.”
Rep. Earl Harris Jr., D-East Chicago, chair of the Indiana Black Legislative Caucus: “Now that the issue of redistricting is finally behind us, it’s time to move on and fight for Hoosiers. This has been a distraction for months, and now, I’m looking forward to working with my caucus and the IBLC to make life better for people throughout the state. The cost of living is simply too high, utility rates are soaring and child care is completely unaffordable—if you can find child care at all. There’s no shortage of issues that Hoosiers are facing every day, and it’s time we get to work to fix them.”
Rep. Alex Burton, D-Evansville: “Today proves that Hoosier voters and voices matter. Outside influence sought to force redistricting and it didn’t work—even in the face of loud voices, swatting and bomb threats.
“Now, the focus can shift to utilities, housing, child care, health care and other important policies needed to ensure a prosperous Indiana, for everyone. Households throughout the State desperately need the legislature to act on their behalf and I’m looking forward to championing legislation that relieves anxiety on payday.
“I’m looking forward to bold action, reasonable policy discussions and a legislative session that keeps Hoosiers first. Families, teachers, small business owners, public safety officers and local elected officials are depending on us.”
House Democratic Leader Phil GiaQuinta, D-Fort Wayne: “I am grateful that Hoosiers, not Washington, D.C., prevailed today. Today is proof that your voice matters in our state government.
“Now that the Senate has rejected mid-decade redistricting, it’s time for state lawmakers to focus on solving what Hoosiers have been begging us to fix: the rising cost of living and impact of tariffs on our economy. Indiana House Democrats are ready to lower the cost of utilities, housing, health care and child care. Let’s get to work for Hoosier wallets!”
TheStatehouseFile.com is a news site powered by Franklin College journalism students.
